Do you believe Liverpool was denied a penalty against Arsenal?

Arsenal secured a 1-0 victory over Liverpool at Anfield, ending their 14-year wait for a win at the ground. The result was an important achievement for Mikel Arteta’s side, who had struggled to secure victories there during that period.

The previous time the Gunners won at Anfield was in 2012, when Arteta was still a player under Arsène Wenger. However, he had never managed to guide Arsenal to victory at the stadium until yesterday, making this result particularly significant for the Spaniard.

An early goal from Kai Havertz proved decisive, with the German once again demonstrating his ability to deliver in important moments. His contribution gave Arsenal the advantage they needed to secure all three points.

Liverpool dominated large periods of the contest, struck the post and created opportunities to score. However, Arsenal defended resolutely and managed to protect their lead, strengthening their position at the top of the Premier League table.

Liverpool left frustrated by penalty decision

Despite Arsenal’s victory, there was considerable controversy surrounding a potential penalty that Liverpool believed should have been awarded. Footage from the match appeared to show Jurrien Timber pulling Alexander Isak’s shirt as the Swedish striker attempted to reach a header inside the penalty area.

Isak remained on his feet following the contact, and VAR did not intervene. The decision angered Liverpool’s players, supporters and manager, who felt their side had been denied an important opportunity to equalise.

(Photo by Eddie Keogh/Getty Images)

Iraola questions officials over Isak incident

Liverpool manager Andoni Iraola was particularly unhappy with the decision and insisted that the contact on Isak should have resulted in a penalty. Speaking after the match, he explained his frustration, as reported by the Daily Mail:

‘There are two situations and they are a little bit related. The Isak one is a clear penalty.

‘He’s gonna head the ball in front of the goal, and they grab him where everyone sees the shirt. You don’t need a lot, just to avoid Alex, because the ball just goes in front of him, and I don’t see the reason why, probably because he doesn’t dive or he doesn’t go to the floor. It shouldn’t be a reason not to concede a penalty.’

The incident added further controversy to an important encounter, although Arsenal ultimately held on to claim a historic victory at Anfield.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
ADMIN COMMENT

So here are some simple rules which I must insist commenters follow….

You agree not to give any personal abuse to other Arsenal fans. Everyone is allowed to hold their own opinions even if you disagree with them. It COSTS NOTHING TO BE POLITE TO OTHER ARSENAL FANS.

CALLING ALL ARSENAL FANS! Anyone who would like to contribute an Article or Video opinion piece on JustArsenal, don’t hesitate to get in touch with us through this link…

Tags Liverpool v Arsenal

28 Comments

Welcome to our Live Comments section, where new comments will appear automatically

Add a Comment
  1. I think if it happened to us we’d be mightily peeved if we didn’t get the decision, but also Nyoni committed 2 yellow card offences in the first 15 minutes so he should have been sent off but didn’t get one booking. The referee had a bad game all round.

    1. 👍Clive Bridgeman. Multiple potentially game altering decisions went both directions on the day. The PL really needs to get better officiating on the pitch and in the VAR booth. Sadly, this has become almost the norm it seems.

  2. In all honesty I think it was a penalty but Isak did not make a big protest at the time.
    And who knows if it would ever have happened if Nyoni had been sent off. It was a very good tight game and was a great win for our beloved Arsenal. If it compares to that game in 1989… no would not say that.

  3. Stone wall penalty, no argument.
    I was genuinely shocked the VAR didn’t recall the ref to take a second look at it on the monitor in the pitch. If it had been us I would have been outraged but I chulk it as one of our lucky breaks.

    1. It wasn’t given. It wasn’t clear and obvious in the opinion of the refereeing team. If the referee had given a penalty, it would probably have stood,
      There was some rationale for the penalty not to be given although it is understandable that many won’t agree.

  4. I’d love to have heard the chat between Izak & Timber following that event. They seemed quite friendly, all things considered.
    Izak probably said, “I should have gone down”, & Timber, “you’re a sweetheart, thanks so much”

  5. I’m looking forward to the article that questions why the referee, assisted by VAR, didn’t issued Nyoni with a straight red card or two yellows in the first fifteen minutes alongside another article explaining why McAlister wasn’t given a straight red for slapping Odegaard around the head and a yellow for play acting while trying to get a fellow professional sent off.

    I wonder if such articles are being discussed on any Liverpool type JA sites or if they are just concentrating on the penalty incident?

    Of course it was a penalty but at least the referee was making consistent errors and didn’t favour one team……perhaps he didn’t want to spoil the spectacle for both sets of fans, rather than thinking about just one set?!

    1. Fulky agree with you ken1945. The nervous Nyoni made Mateta like fouls in quick succession but the ref condoned him. Man City scored 3 at Anfield after Gravenberch saw red. Same could have happened if Nyoni was sent off

    2. Ken, there’s an article in the Athletic today, the weekly “ask the ref”, and obviously, much of this comes up. And surprisingly, ex- Premier League ref Graham Scott thinks that this was not a penalty, due to Izak not being actually impeded, even though Timber had hold of his shirt, it didn’t affect his leap, and that because they were friendly afterwards, Izak didn’t appear to have even noticed it, and his team mates were not bothered by it either. Which was true, the whole incident was bizarre.
      Very good read if you have the time.

      1. Jax, Scott has a valid point. Perhaps we all jumped to conclusions regarding whether it was a penalty in addition to it being the holding of a shirt. Honestly, I didn’t think about anything other than seeing that his shirt was held while he was going for the ball. Some things are seen to be automatic when they are not necessarily. If Madley and Attwell were in fact way ahead of us on this one then they should be commended and just tarred and feathered on their other decisions, lol.

          1. No matter whether it affected him or not though, grabbing an opponents shirt is not allowed and a free kick/oenalty should be awarded.
            If not, it would mean that referees would have the opportunity to decide if the offence merited punishment or not and that’s why we’re seeing all this reaction.

            Imagine for instance Mr Oliver decides that tugging Haarland’s shirt merits a penalty, while not giving a penalty when the same thing happens to Gyokeres as it would spoil the spectacle of the game!!

            There has to be clear cut rules so neither players or officials can cop out of situations.
            Grabbing hold of an opponent’s shirt/shorts/hair/ is either a foul or it isn’t and there should be no grey areas that allows fudging to be introduced!!
            I thought that was in place at the start of this season?!

            1. According to the FA rule 12, if a player holds an opponent or impedes an opponent with contact, a direct free kick (penalty inside the area) is awarded. I can’t anything that provides that shirt contact in and of itself is specifically given as an action always requiring the giving of the direct free kick. From my reading of the law, this does appear to be a grey area. Does he “hold” the opponent or impede him with contact? It allows for an interpretation of whether these criteria were met and I agree, the less grey areas, the better.

            2. It is incorrect to state that a free kick or penalty should be awarded for grabbing a shirt. It depends, amongst other things, on whether the action is judged to impede the player whose shirt is grabbed. Discretion is needed and this is an essential part of refereeing. Otherwise, you are calling for a robotic interpretation of the rules which would make the game poorer.

        1. Interesting read Jax as he seems to be saying it’s not a hard and fast rule regarding shirt holding, but rather a referee’s opinion.

          I’ve just submitted an article on the four msjor contentious issue’s during the Liverpool match and coming at it from a different angle – your thoughts, if the article is published, would be most welcome 👍

  6. For me it was a penalty and I’d be furious if it happened to us and a penalty wasn’t given. Mind you there’s been instances where we’ve been denied a stone wall penalty in the past.

  7. Herr Drier,

    Regards us being denied stone wall penalty’s in the past, I think it fair to say that all teams can claim that.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Top Blog Sponsors