In-depth analysis of the positions and player roles in football (Midfielders)

Understanding the positions and player roles in football (Midfielders) by Eddie

These next set of guys are seen as the backbone of every team sometimes. They’re the ones next in line after your defenders. They’re the ones to balance your play from the defense to attack, they’re known for transitioning the game. Also they’re known to be the secondary defenders. Right before you face the defenders, these are the guys you need to beat first.

Without too wasting much time.

The Midfielders:

Position: The Midfield
Role: The Center Midfielder(CM):
These guys are the first and foremost, the playmakers and influencers of the game. These are the guys who link the attack with the defense. You need these guys if you want to dominate the midfield. These guys are meant to contribute to the team in terms of Goals, assists and creating the chances, and making key decisions. Known players in this position includes Hernandez Xavi, Andres Iniesta, Luka Modric, Santi Cazorla, etc.

Position: The Defensive/Holding Midfielder(DM):
This position is so important in the game of football, in this position there are two important roles, their jobs varies and they offer different outlets to the game. To the average football fan, they’re both known as Defensive Midfielders, but technically they’re not tasked with the same duty

Role 1: Ball-Winning midfielder(BWM)

Always stationed deep and base of the midfield. These guys are the workhorse of the team. These are the guys who play, and are assigned,directly in front of the defenders. Their main and primary objective is to retrieve the ball from the opponents as many times as possible and distributing it to the nearest midfielder, anticipate rival passes and play then intercept those passes. They provide cover for the team when the attack is on likewise when it’s time to defend. These guys are strong, physical, tenacious, rugged and can contest the ball physically with opponents, technical abilities are added bonuses. They are mobile players who need to cover and chase opponents, they’re tasked with the responsibility of stopping opponents before getting to the defense line. This is one position coaches and teams makes sure they get covered. On this list you have Iconic names like Gattuso, Claude Makelele, Patrick Vieira, Sergio Busquets, and others include Thiago Motta, Sami Khedira, Fernandinho, Ngolo Kante, Casemiro, our own Lucas Torreira etc.

· Sits in front of the defence
· Wins the ball back with tackles and interceptions
· Covers teammates when they go forward
· Harries opposition attackers
· Physically fit and tenacious

Position: The Defensive Midfielder(DM)

Role 2: The Deep-Lying Playmakers(DLM):

These are the guys you find next to the holding midfielders. In tactical setups in football, attacking playmakers are stationed up front at the head of the midfield, and those who play behind them (CM,DM,DLP,B2B) are all required to move the ball forward to him.

In modern day football and tactical setups, these are the playmakers responsible for operating from deep. This role is being achieved from the base of the midfield, deep alongside the holding midfielder. These are the guys who can control the tempo of the game from the base of midfield. This role is very important to teams and coaches who play the possession-based game. (Maybe this is why Emery is obsessed with Xhaka as long as Ozil doesn’t play? If he needs a DLP so bad, why not get a new one?)

This position is very important in the game of football today, the DLP is not just the DM guy who provides cover at the midfield base, he’s not the CM who drops back to get the ball before pushing it up front or wide. These are the guys whose primary and chief duty is to dictate the tempo of the game right from the base of midfield. This position demands intelligence, Vision, ability to switch play. They are tasked with making intelligent passes, short passes, long passes, to pass through and break the opposition’s midfield and defensive line. They’re meant to orchestrate attacks from the back.

Secondary duties includes providing cover for the defense alongside the holding midfielder, retrieving the ball from the opponents, intercepting passes. They share a bit of the responsibilities given to the Holding midfielders. Perhaps this is why Deep-Lying Playmakers are often mistaken as Holding and Ball-winning midfielders. The best and the only one regarded as the very best in the DLP role is Andrea Pirlo. Make a search, and the first name you’ll pick up is Pirlo. Iconic names includes, Xabi Alonso, Toni Kroos, Sergio Busquets (Garnered respect and accolades all over the world of football, Regarded as the world’s best DM in his prime because of his abilities, this man is the hybrid of the DM and DLP. This man alongside two of the very best CM? Xavi and Iniesta? We all know how they dominated the midfield); Cesc Fabregas, Thiago Alcantara, Marco Verratti (This man can do literally everything in football, defend and create pinpoint passes from anywhere, no wonder Barcelona chased him for years and PSG refused to let him go); Ilkay Gundogan, Granit Xhaka, Marcelo Brozovic, Dani Parejo, Jorginho (The reason Pep tried to acquire him and Sarri brought him to England, he wasted no time in breaking the EPL’s record for number of most passes in a single game just under a month); etc.

All in all, these guys are the ones replacing the attacking midfielders, because of their ability to dictate the tempo and control the game.

· Sits in front of the defence
· Creative playmaker from deep
· Distributes to teammates, near and far
· Sets the team’s tempo
· Capable of tackling, though a secondary task

Role 3: The Box to Box Midfielders(B2B):
This is the guy who runs from his box to the opposition’s box just to fulfill different roles on the pitch. Perhaps arguably the most hardworking role when compared to the BWM. These are the guys who are experts at playing both Offense and Defense. This role demands the quality to create chances for strikers and stop the opposition’s attackers, strength, technical abilities, Stamina and strength, and must be a relentless hard worker. The non-stop dynamism of this position makes it also a very important role in today’s game. He’s a big threat from distance. These guys can do everything in the middle of the park.

The best player known in this position is Steven Gerard, other iconic names includes Yaya Toure, Bastian Schweinsteiger, Arturo Vidal, Claudio Marchisio, Esteben Cambiasso, others includes, Gabi, Moussa Sissoko, Aaron Ramsey, Daniele De Rossi, Alex Song etc

· Lines up in the middle of the field
· Equally adept at attacking and defending
· Maintains possession
· Tracks back to tackle and block shots
· Breaks into the opponent’s box and tries to score

Role 4: The Wide Midfielder:
These guys are the ones to add width to your midfield, they possess strength and pace because they need to perform the role of a winger during the game. They also provide cover and protection for the fullbacks.
These midfielders can also cross the ball into the opponents box from halfway line unlike the wingers. They tend to whip in Beckhamesque-like crosses. I’ll say the Wingback is the modern day WM only difference is with the WM, you have a Fullback on the pitch also. On this list, iconic names includes, David Beckham, Ze Roberto, and others like Angel Di Maria, Kevin De Bruyne, etc.

Position: Wide midfielder
· Provides width in midfield
· Gives full-backs defensive protection
· Compresses play in opponents’ half
· May cross from deeper positions than wingers
· Combines speed and stamina

Role 5: The Attacking Midfielders A.k.a The Number 10:
They are not required to be the fastest or to be blessed with pace, after all the ball is stuck at their feet whether they run with it or not. These guys have creativity oozing all over their body, they are widely known as the superstars. In the history of football, some of the game’s very best were attacking Midfielders. Generally assigned the Jersey number 10. Their role is similar to the Center midfielder role, but they focus more on attacking, scoring, making assists and shooting. Unlike the DLP, these guys are stationed just behind the attackers and the do everything else for the attackers. Qualities required in this role involves field vision, technique, and ball control, must-have abilities for these guys are exquisite techniques and accuracy, be it shot or pass. Both qualities are the most important to be able to manipulate the ball to their will. Also they’re known to be in charge of free kicks and penalties. Legendary players in this position are so many that I might forget some players, but these legends includes Zinedine Zidane, Dennis Bergkamp, Francesco Totti, Ronaldinho, Austin Jay Jay Okocha, Ricardo Kaka, David Silva, Mesut Ozil, Marco Reus, James Rodriguez, Philippe Coutinho, (Lionel Messi?), etc. Sadly enough the position for these guys is slowly dying off and being abandoned by the modern football managers.

· Dictates play from behind the strikers
· Creates goalscoring chances for the attackers
· Technique and creativity crucial
· Ability to shoot from range an advantage
· Historically associated with the Jersey number 10.

So, I hope most of us understand these roles better now. Xhaka isn’t our Defensive midfielder, as that’s what the average fan know as a ball winning midfielder. Torreira is that player and it’s the reason we got him in the first place. Xhaka is so bad at tackling that Arsene Wenger asked him to stop and not bother himself after he got a red card in 2017. Our midfield started getting exposed after Torreira’s MOTM performance against Spurs last season. Torreira has been playing as our CM not DM for the record. Emery needs to fix this Asap and let the man play his Kante role.

Next and finally!!

The attackers…..

Eddie Hoyte

15 Comments

  1. Innit says:

    For well over a decade Wenger didn’t take the position of Defensive Midfielder seriously enough to our detriment

    Torreira needs to play this position

    1. 350oz says:

      Agree, for many years Wenger insistence with technical players has been costly. Imagine a proper DM behind Cazorla, Ozil, T.Rosicky, Wilshere, and Ramsey.

  2. Sean Williams says:

    Interesting article and well explained. Whether one thinks the way you articulate or not one thing that stands out. That is when a player is clearly not good enough for the role a) set out for him, b) not good enough compared to players in other teams and c) just not good enough at all. To me Xhaka is just not good enough. It would not be possible to challenge for the league title with him in the team. At the moment I would think the majority of supporters would say so. Sometimes players can improve and move up a notch, particularly young players. Some player just had it, such as Fabregas. But with Xhaka there are mental and physical limitations. As said before. You ‘cannot turn a pig’s ear into a silk purse’. Xhaka is factually not good enough and holds us back from discovering our accuracy, our speed, our intensity and our consistency. Hopefully like with Mustafi, Emery will wake up to this sooner than later.

  3. Dan kit says:

    No inverted wingers with dead legs and 15 toes Eddie !!! I thought that would have been your 1st choice there .

    1. Eddie says:

      ?No Dan, I couldn’t do that to Gotanidea… Let him write the article on Inverted wingers with dead legs

  4. 350oz says:

    No, Xhaka is the DM because he is positioned between CB and CM, don’t confuse positional placement DM-CM-AM with players role (ball winning midfielder, DLP, B2B, advanced playmaker).
    For example Kevin De Bruyne, Santi Cazorla, or Ozil were often positioned wide (wide MF) but they drifted to the center and performed the classic number 10 role (advanced playmaker).

    1. Eddie says:

      you’re only confusing yourself brother, I know the position in midfield placement being DM-CM-AM.
      This is why I wrote this article, it’s what spurned me into writing this.
      They don’t share the sane role or responsibilities, they are called DM by the average football fan and supporter but they have their qualities and roles. Xhaka is not a Ball-winning midfielder, understand the point, there’s no sense in expecting him to perform that role.
      At Monchengladbach, Xhaka played alongside a standard no 4, a ball winning midfielder.
      He’s a Deep-Lying playmaker, don’t expect him to be the one doing your defensive duties.
      Hell even the Bundesliga official describe tackling as secondary roles for DLP.
      Xhaka can’t do Torreira or Kante’s job.
      Even Arsene Wenger asked him to stop tackling since he’s very bad at it and it’s his secondary role.
      It’s like expecting Pirlo to be your ball winning midfielder.
      it’s insane

      1. 350oz says:

        I’m not confused bro, and I’ve never said his role is to win the ball (a.k.a. ball winning midfielder). I wholeheartedly agree with you Xhaka is a DLP (his role) but he is a DM (his position). Let’s say in 4-2-3-1 formation, the two holding midfielders are Pirlo and Gatusso, positionally they are both DM. Of course their roles differ (one is DLP and the other one is BWM).

        In the past, I saw Sir Alex assigned Park Ji Sung a wide midfielder position, but he’d never advanced and he was instructed to guard the flank. In that case, Ji Sung position was a Wide Midfielder and his role was a defensive wide or dare I say, a BWM.

        1. Eddie says:

          350oz I get your drift now, but what’s the point in assigning Xhaka in a position we know he’s useless at? Even Arsene Wenger knew he’s a bad tackler.

          1. 350oz says:

            That I don’t know Eddie ?
            He is a big liability defensively, I read after 100 games he made seven errors directly contributing to goals (the fourth highest in PL).

  5. S.J says:

    For me our best midfield 3 are Ceballos, Guendouzi, Torreria.

    CAM – Ceballos, De Bruyne, Wijnaldium, Mount.
    CM – Guendouzi, D. Silva, Henderson, Jorginho.
    DM – Torreria, Rodri, Fabinho, Kante.

    I believe in our midfield but compared to other midfield I see our’s is young and youthful though they can still match up with the best if they always give there all.

  6. Jackoboms says:

    A combination of Cellabos (playing 10), Guendouzi (Playing 8) and Toreira (Playing 4) will make Arsenal go far this season.

    Lacazette

    Aubameyang Ceballos Pepe

    Guendouzi Toreira

    Kolašinac Luiz Chambers AMN

    LENO

    Tierney replaces Kolasinac, Holding replaces Chambers and Bellerin replaces AMN when back to the pitch

    Note: AMN is not suited for right back. Get a new RB in January.

    Sub
    —-

    1. Martinez (GK)
    2. Ozil
    3. Xhaka
    4. Martinelli
    5. WIllock
    6. Monreal
    7. Sokratis

    Arsenal has a very brilliant squad. The coach just needs to utilize the team appropriately.

  7. Liam Gallagher says:

    Guendouzi is the only midfielder we own that will be or is at the required quality. Willock can get there. Xhaka and Torriera aren’t good enough.

  8. Declan says:

    Appreciate your efforts Eddie but this is the third article recently on the subject of educating us about positions and their descriptions and all three have been different. Just shows how subjective the subject is. Just to be clear to everyone, Torriera is a DM and that’s where he started with us and then Emery moved him forward to play B2B. Perhaps you should email this article to Emery to educate him !

  9. Kat de Luna says:

    great article Eddie, am a young man who play football & this is very educative on midfield roles & duty although i play as an attckin 9 or a supportin 8. i would like to contribute on the number 10(AM). There 2 types of attackin midfielders 10’s in modern football 1. a classic no.10 aka false 9 (force attacks, scores, dribbles, assist, distribute).eg messi, kaka, hazard etc 2. a golden no. 10 (doesn’t always force attack but keeps possesion, assist, top disributor & only attempt dribbles in tight spaces. eg okocha, ozil, ronaldinho etc. these are the dying breed.

Comments are closed