I cannot complain about our choice of a new Sporting Director, given that Atlético Madrid have long been the template I wished Arsenal would follow.
It is not just that Andrea Berta oversaw the Spanish club ending a two-decade title drought (sound familiar?) or that the team consistently punched above their weight in Europe—lifting the Europa League and reaching two Champions League finals under his tenure. What should give Gooners hope is that the Italian subscribes to the ethos that to be a big club, you must act like one.
The truth does not always matter because perception can become reality. Atlético have long been Real Madrid’s little brother in the Spanish capital, living off the scraps of the 15-time Champions of Europe. Financially, they have struggled for most of their history to compete with Spain’s two footballing giants. Yet those in power at the Metropolitano have never accepted that as an excuse for not being competitive; they have simply found another way.
It takes strong personalities to uphold such principles. Clearly, Diego Simeone possesses that strength—an ability to extract every ounce of potential from the resources available to him—and it is evident that he surrounds himself with individuals who share the same outlook.
It is worth noting that while Mr Berta cited wanting a new challenge as the reason for handing in his notice, many sources close to him suggest he made the decision as soon as he sensed he would no longer have the control he once held. While I believe he will be working with an ambitious manager in North London, I am less convinced about those who will be paying his wages.
I cannot be the only one who saw the irony when Stan Kroenke was the one declaring, “Anyone who knows the sport!” Ask our owner to name his greatest Gunners XI or our next three fixtures. Since first joining the board, the Kroenke family have adhered to a self-sustaining model, meaning the likes of Chelsea and Manchester City can offer bigger fees and wages.
That makes Mr Berta well-suited for this role, as he not only knows how to work within financial constraints but also demands creativity from those around him. There is no way the Italian would have accepted what happened in January when our recruitment team effectively waved the white flag in the title race. Whether it was scouting a hidden gem, leveraging his networks to find value, or securing a loan deal, a solution would have been found to strengthen our attack.

By most metrics, Arsenal are a bigger club than Atlético Madrid. However, based on the 54-year-old’s 12-year tenure in Spain, Atlético’s global reputation has grown, while Arsenal have regressed. Too many assets have been allowed to run down their contracts due to a fear of fan backlash, diminishing their value.
In Madrid, they never begged players to stay; instead, they made significant profits and reinvested in the squad. Often, individuals who left found themselves missing Atlético’s unique culture and returned when it made business sense (Griezmann and Costa). They conducted themselves like a big club by being smart enough to acknowledge they were not.
Arsenal would never have loaned a goalkeeper for years (as Atlético did with Courtois) due to concerns about appearing like a stepping stone. Yet, how much did Atlético benefit from that deal?
While Berta has contacts for identifying young talent, he has never shied away from signing experienced professionals if it made sense. Our transfer policy would have ruled out signing Luis Suárez at 33 due to concerns over resale value. In the short term, however, that move secured Atlético the La Liga title—because winning is part of the philosophy too.
That winning ethos, which Mr Berta helped to instil, is why we should welcome his presence in the Emirates corridors. Whether he will be listened to when it truly matters is another question entirely.
______________________________________________________________________________________
ADMIN COMMENT
So here are some simple rules which I must insist commenters follow….
You agree not to give any personal abuse to other Arsenal fans. Everyone is allowed to hold their own opinions even if you disagree with them. It COSTS NOTHING TO BE POLITE TO OTHER ARSENAL FANS.
CALLING ALL ARSENAL FANS! Anyone who would like to contribute an Article or Video opinion piece on JustArsenal, please contact us through this link…




Not necessarily the Atlético Madrid model, been the little brother to the cemetery of talents is not ideal, we are a big club in our own right.
But if Berta was just a big fish in a small pond, only time will tell.
Arsenal new Sporting director has to be someone that can tempered the gaffer impulses on players acquisition
Doesn’t matter if they won La Liga and got to CL Finals
More then we have done in a while
He also made Atletico Madrid pay £113m for Joao Felix and £25m for Matheus Cunha, yet Diego Simeone was 100% blamed for those players’ performance
Hopefully his future players’ resale values will compensate for his future mistakes
Just because a transfer doesn’t work doesn’t always mean it was a mistake. If I remember correctly,Joao Felix was considered one of the biggest prospects in world football at the time . Every top club in Europe wanted him and that obviously drove up his price. Atletico won the race and the rest is history.
Hindsight is 20/20 and that’s why it’s easy to say it was a mistake after the fact. I don’t remember any football fans saying he’d be a flop. As a matter of fact,everyone wanted their club to sign him. It was hailed by many as the signing that was going to elevate Atletico to the level of two giants,Barca and Madrid. It wasn’t a mistake, it just didn’t work out.
Even in our daily lives,there are decisions we make or relationships we get into or businesses/jobs we get into that make sense when we get into them but fail down the line.Doesn’t always mean they were mistakes. Stuff sometimes just doesn’t pan out for various unexpected reasons. For Felix, I think the football world has moved on from a player like him and he hasn’t adapted his game to play other roles.He would have been great as a classic number 10 like Özil.
One of a sporting director’s responsibility is overseeing player scouting, not just listen to the hype
He was obviously impressed by Joao Felix’s stats as many scouts, managers and fans were, but a highly-experienced technical football executive like him should’ve known that Joao Felix’s football style and abilities didn’t match with Diego Simeone’s ultra-defensive tactics
If Joao Felix’s move to Madrid wasn’t a mistake, Nicolas Pepe’s transfer to Arsenal wasn’t a mistake either. That logic means Pepe just didn’t work out for Emery and Arteta
Pepe was definitely a mistake because it was established that Arsenal overpaid for him. I believe someone was even sacked because of this. It’s different from Felix.
Atletico likely saw him as the replacement for Grieazmann. There was every reason to believe this was going to work because he’s a similar kind of player to the Frenchman who was successful at Atletico.Even though Simeone’s style is ultra defensive,lots of attacking players have thrived there.
I don’t think it was just hype with Felix. He’s clearly talented and that’s why even the likes of Barcelona wanted him. Maybe it’s just a mentality issue with him or he doesn’t work hard enough.
Sure it’s the director’s job to scout, but what if it’s the director’s boss, the CEO ,who wants the player,like in the case of Felix. Can he overrule his boss? I don’t think so. Maybe it’s because of such things that he left Atletico in the first place.
Whilst I agree that circumstances were different between these players it was always going to be huge gamble paying that much money for such a young player with limited experience and impact to that point. I don’t see how one could have been that confident that he would seamlessly fit Into Atletico’s system or Griezmann’s shoes to pay such an outrageous fee.
Why are you always pointing out the joao Felix Cunha deal? How many wrong signings did Edu and Arteta make in the past few years?
Just wanted to show that Berta isn’t really much better than Edu
He’s better at building winning teams
Also from what I’ve gathered, it was actually Atletico CEO Gil Marin who pushed for the Joao Felix signing,traveling to Portugal personally to convince the highly sought after youngster. He was to be the main man for their project.
I dont think the article is implying that he is beyond reproach…but his achievements and what he brings to the table vastly outweigh his mistakes…i for one am excited about his appointment
I’ll take the talent and experience but hopefully leave the Atletico model in Madrid. Arsenal have to do better than that.
Better then winning la Liga ?
Worth noting that while Felix was a flop and cost Athletico 127 million euros, Berta did manage to get 11 million loan fee from Chelsea, 7 million loan fee from Barcelona and finally 52 million out of Chelsea when he was sold.
57 million loss is a lot but ie. we’ve let 80 million Pepe and 63 million Aubameyang leave for free. Matter of of fact, I think we actually paid them to leave.
I think bringing back Diego Costa for 60 million and him leaving for free couple years later, has been Berta’s worst transfer.
I agree with the writer to the extent that he will bring unique qualities that will improve the squad and make us more competitive.
That said, I don’t think there’s any need for a change in our model or ethos . I think Arsenal already has a good model and ethos that can be traced back to the days of Wenger. Berta can work within the existing model with his unique qualities.
I also don’t think Arsenal has regressed. The club has progressed on the pitch and as a brand over the past few years. This is why we’ve been able to pull big talent like Rice, who was also wanted by other big clubs. In my part of the world,no one knows about Atletico. Everyone knows about Arsenal.
About the Kroenkes,I disagree and agree at the same time. The senior Kroenke doesn’t seem to be interested in ‘soccer’. You can’t say the same about his son Josh though. From what I can tell,Josh is very much involved and active.
Seimone made Berta look good! On a shoe string budget the man won 2 Europa, 2 La Liga titles, 2 Super Cups and 2 domestic cups in 14 years with AM while always being competitive. Compare that with Mikel. 1 FA with Emery’s squad! Good luck to Berta.
Sometimes signing a player cannot guarantee success, signing is a grumble in the environment where things change so often. Take epl it’s a type of league you can expect a player to adapt immediately owing to its physicality and poor officiating.