The Mikel Arteta era at Arsenal has reached a painful stalemate. While he has undeniably raised the floor of the club, his obsession with a specific brand of controlled football appears to be the very thing preventing the team from reaching its ceiling. By demanding excessive caution during high pressure moments of the season, Arteta does not just manage the game, he removes the freedom from his players, turning a title charge into an exercise in frustration for the fans.
The continued reliance on Kai Havertz is the clearest example of this stubbornness. Despite being signed for a significant fee, Havertz frequently fails to excel in midfield, often looking lost in transition. While his supporters point to isolated decisive moments, his overall impact has been inconsistent. Statistically, his ball retention in tight spaces has been criticised, with metrics suggesting high rates of possession loss in competitive matches, leaving the Arsenal engine room exposed.
Looking ahead, the pursuit of Viktor Gyokeres raises similar concerns. Rather than being a dominant focal point, he has shown technical limitations in certain aspects of his game. He can struggle to hold up play or control difficult passes, and his lack of intricate footwork could be exposed by elite Premier League defenders. For a club seeking a clinical finisher, investing in a striker who may not consistently deliver at that level would represent a significant risk.
In midfield, the reported interest in Martin Zubimendi also brings questions. While he is praised for his technical qualities, he can be vulnerable under pressure when building from the back. In the high intensity environment of English football, even a single misplaced pass in deep areas can prove costly, yet Arteta appears drawn to system players who may struggle with the physical demands of the league.
Control Versus Courage In The Title Run In
The defensive line also raises concerns about loyalty over performance, particularly regarding Ben White. Despite being a regular starter, he has been involved in several costly defensive moments during crucial stages of previous seasons. His possession statistics in pressured situations highlight the risks within a system built so heavily on control. Retaining players who may have reached their limit could prevent the club from recruiting the elite level talent required to win major honours.
The trophy record tells a difficult story. Aside from the FA Cup early in his tenure, Arteta has overseen a prolonged period without major silverware. There is a growing concern that even a breakthrough title could reinforce a cautious approach, potentially leading to further near misses in future seasons.
Tactically, Arteta can appear reluctant to adapt. His system often encourages a reactive approach, with Arsenal absorbing pressure rather than imposing themselves on games. This mentality becomes particularly visible in decisive moments of the season, where hesitation replaces authority.
Arteta’s focus on control, once a key strength, now risks becoming a limitation. In crucial matches, the team can shift away from proactive football, adopting a more defensive mindset that invites pressure. This approach can transfer uncertainty to the players, turning a confident side into one that reacts rather than dictates.
The narrative around Arsenal falling short is no longer just external criticism, it is becoming a recurring pattern. If the team once again fails to convert a strong position into a title, questions about mentality and leadership will only intensify. A manager’s role at this level is to guide players through pressure, not to amplify it.
A Cycle That Must Be Broken
This season has presented an opportunity, with rivals dropping points and the title race remaining open. Failing to capitalise in such circumstances would point to deeper issues than simple misfortune, raising concerns about leadership and decision making at the highest level.
Arsenal is a club that should be competing for the biggest honours consistently, not one that settles for coming close. The league has offered opportunities, yet Arteta’s approach can appear more focused on maintaining structure than taking decisive risks to secure success.
If this pattern continues, it will strengthen the argument that change is required. The club cannot afford to remain in a cycle of near success without delivering major trophies. At some stage, difficult decisions must be made.
Watching Arsenal should not feel like an exercise in frustration. The expectation is to compete, to challenge, and ultimately to win. If the current leadership cannot deliver that progression, then the club must consider whether a new direction is needed.
What do you think Gooners? Is Arteta’s approach holding Arsenal back, or is patience still required to achieve success?
Reader Opinion – FAMOCHI
_______________________________________________________________________________________
ADMIN COMMENT
So here are some simple rules which I must insist commenters follow….
You agree not to give any personal abuse to other Arsenal fans. Everyone is allowed to hold their own opinions even if you disagree with them. It COSTS NOTHING TO BE POLITE TO OTHER ARSENAL FANS.
CALLING ALL ARSENAL FANS! Anyone who would like to contribute an Article or Video opinion piece on JustArsenal, don’t hesitate to get in touch with us through this link…
The moment Arteta decided to ship Xhaka out is when we lost any form of interesting attacking output.
Zero number of player in the current squad with over-the-top ball skills. Xhaka used to do it for fun and hence we saw the best of Martinelli, Saka, Odegaard run at will at terrified PL defenders as Xh pings accurate passes from deep. Teams never dared to wander too too far off their backlines knowing the lethal attackers we have waiting on the byline. Unlike now when everyone takes a fancy at running at us at will. But sure MA doesnt want that kind of effective football, thus Xhaka just when he found a useful role in the squad, had to go.
Cue stifling, suffocating side-ways, zero urgency football with no aim. The only time in the last couple of season I was really thrilled or happy in a game is on the rare chances when a player breaks away, a la Martinelli and Dowman. A 3:38 ratio over the course of a season’s football.
The rest is dreary, stomach-churning football.
Hope my TV survives another futile, time-frigging wasting throwing attempts that gets immediately recycled to the opponent and put us immediately under pressure.
Even if he wins the PL, we are more likely to witness more of the same as he will double-down on a “winning strategy”. Cant even bear to think of the torture of Arsenal football seasons to come. Ok, enough!
Jadedfan, Arsenal didn’t decide “to ship Xhaka out.” In fact, they very much wanted him to stay, but I think he probably knew his playing time was limited with the likely arrival of Rice. So it was his own choice to leave, and we did get a reasonable price for an aging player.
Jadedfan
Let us be factual even if some of you want to blame Arteta for everything
1. Arsenal fans wanted Xhaka gone after his controversial encounter with the fans. Who changed that animosity? It’s Arteta. Even Xhaka acknowledges that. Let us not pretend we love him 100%. In fact, Xhaka performed well under Arteta than under Wenger and Emery
2. Xhaka left because of family issues, not because of Arteta. It was contributed more by his wife
3. Rice has outperformed him in the same position. That’s why everyone has been talking about a Ballon D’or for him
He Is. He’s a control freak that feels out of control when players use their natural attributes instead of his rigid, predictable routines.
Arteta is also overly superstitious, and treats it like it’s a science.
Arteta is more afraid to lose than he is keen to win. So yes his fear is holding them back
Unless Arteta drops Zubimendi for the rest of the decisive games, we will not win PL not alone CL
I’ve had this thought that yes we are in a bit of a crisis in terms of confidence, but I get myself up by knowing we should have some players coming back from injury soon which could boost the team.
Problem is however, as the article suggests, no matter what players become available, Arteta’s grip on them is so tight that they aren’t really allowed to express themselves, so it makes no difference.
With that said, I hope Arteta let’s the players express themselves a bit tonight, we need a game with a few goals to lift the team before the weekend! I know it is the CL QF, and we must treat it with the respect it deserves, but for once just trust the players and let them play.
I just won’t feel confident going into the City115 game off the back of another cagey, nervy affair.
Just to add, it is quite ironic that Arteta says things like he wants, “no fear”, “pure fire” from the players.
Then when playing he cripples them.
I just hope this changes.
Kia
Arteta is not as strict as people always say he is
Look at Eze’s goal against Leverkusen, Madueke’s and Dowman’s license to dribble, Martinelli’s run again Sporting Lisbon, Calafiori’s license to roam all over the field, Rice’s license to make runs and long passes amd shoot from afar. . These few examples don’t say that Arteta restricts his players as Arsenal fans always want to say
Even if we were to win the League and the European Championship, our squad needs to be revamped for next season.After watching PSG on a number of occasions ,they are a side without weakness ,certainly as far as their first 11/14 is concerned, and apart from the individual skills of their players ,the thing that impressed me is their prodigious energy and work rate with and without the ball.They are not an imposing side physically, but their back four are all blessed with pace, and their midfield trio buzz around the opposition constantly.They are rarely more than 10 yards apart and supported by their athletic front three ,they are a formidable force in defence and when they attack.In essence they are a joy to watch and i only wish Arsenal could emulate them.To do so, we need to add pace and energy to our squad if we are to be successful next season as too many of our current squad are lacking in these respects.Finally they have a terrific Keeper who plays it safe and sensible with his feet and is not averse to going long to relieve pressure when necessary.Of course to play tactically like PSG would involve a major change in the outlook of our Manager who i suspect would be reluctant to rethink his risk averse ideology.Funny that the pressure which is mounting on Arteta, on JA and elsewhere, comes at a time when Bournemouth have announced the imminent departure of their excellent Manager who’s team play a brand of football ,which like PSG, is a joy to watch!
I agree Grandad, I am so jealous when I watch PSG play, it reminds me of the good old days!
Grandad, what I find weird, is that we are talking about revamping the squad that, at the start of the season, looked so strong in every department.
Injuries to players such as Timber, Califiori, Hincapie, Saka, Odegaard, Merino, along with the seeming reluctance of MA to select players such as Norgaard, Lewis Skelly and Nwaneri has made that idea of a strong squad seem just wishful thinking.
If those injured players were actually available, I’m not so sure that we would need to revamp at all and, if MA was to use players liker Norgaard etc it would make even more sense to say we had a very good squad of players.
I’m looking forward to tonight’s game inasmuch as we will see if the “fire” MA is talking about actually comes to fruition on the pitch – if not, I believe we will see the third part of the quadruple disappear as quickly as the other two!!!
Ken,part of the required revamp relates to peripheral figures such as loanees, like Nelson and Veira.In terms of non performing assets I suspect Jesus,Trossard ,MSL and perhaps Havertz may be moved on if possible which leads to the third group of decidedly injury prone guys such as Calafiori and Odegaard.Then we have the strange case of Norgaard, signed by our Manager but rarely used despite being fit and entirely capable?Furthermore, in terms of quality would any of our front three options start for PSG? .I think not.Injuries have undoubtedly impacted on our performances but to my mind we need to strengthen our squad regardless of where we finish in the League or the outcome of our challenge in the elite European competition.
1. Arteta has done great since becoming our manager. We were a joke before he came. We were celebrating finishing 4th. He has also failed a lot, and I believe he will still come short many times as he continues to learn
2. There are some coaches who have done the near misses
– Ferguson won the League after 6 years. He won his first Champions League trophy for Man United after 13 years. He also lost 2 Champions League finals, as well as League titles to Arsenal and Man City
– Klopp lost some Champions League finals before winning it eventually. He also lost some league titles to Man City
– Tuchel lost Bundelisga title to Bayer Leverkusen
3. Until the season ends, we should support the coach
wouldn’t say he’s done great
need to stop pretending he’s remade the wheel
a good job but not a great one
Dan
It depends on what you understand by great
For me, taking your first job at a Big club like Arsenal, and transforming them from top 4 hopefuls to Title Challengers in four consecutive seasons against Some of the best coaches in Klopp, Pep, and Mourinho is not a small thing. Remember also, his first Champions League ended in a Quarter Final loss to Bayern Munich, the Second was a Semi final loss against eventual winners Psg and the third one hopefully will also see us in another Semis, the first back to back semis In history
We have made big steps since he came in. Hopefully, he will the league or the champions league
I totally understand your point about “great”. It’s open to interpretation although in its proper context it’s a word often over magnified. In this case Arteta has done a great job overall, considering the points you raised in your reply
@Freddy
Recognize Artetack contributions so far ..
He’d done excellently well enough… However, overtime consistently imploding himself when it matter make me worry on fourth consecutive time and please tell me about the relevance of Harvert in middle in all his all games at same position so let’s be frank except we’re contended with the level we’re now so then, I’ll call for a change now than wondering why we shouldn’t have taken this big leap earlier in later future.
We need a impactful middle ball works than his over rigid side ways pass which is mostly very predictable now.
FAMOCHI
1. I find it funny when I see Arsenal fans complaining when Havertz is playing as a 10. Do you know why?
– When Havertz came to Arsenal, Arteta played him as a striker. Arsenal fans started complaining, asking why he was playing a midfielder as a striker, since he had been bought to replace Xhaka. Then Arteta made him a better striker, especially in the last months of the season when he was scoring consistently. In that first season, we scored a record 91 league goals, because Havertz made us unpredictable, with goals coming from all sides
– If you go back to when Havertz was at Leverkusen, you will realise that he is actually the most creative midfielders we have. That was evident thos season the first time he played with Gyokeres. He was always finding Gyokeres with ease with accurate through passes, something Odegaard struggled with. Even Arsenal fans started saying that he should be playing with Gyokeres. The same fans are now complaining
2. As for side way passing. I see a lot of fans saying Arteta ball is always passing sideways
– Now, can you explain to me like a kid how that can be true, considering that we have scored 62 league goals in the league (Only 1 behind Man City), and were the top scorers in the Champions League league phase
– Again, how did we beat Bayern Munich, Inter Milan, Atletico, Bilbao, Spurs home and away, Man United away, Chelsea three times by playing sideway passes? Are we truthful or do we complain for the sake of complaining?
to me a Pep Guardiola, Sir Alex , Mr Wenger are greats
Arteta isn’t the only manager who walked into a club with issues
most clubs who change managers do so for that reasons
he’s done allot of good things and I’m happy for him to stay but given the money he spent this season I can’t with good faith say others wouldn’t have equally managed a runners up finish
lets hope though this ends a great season
last two lines. Are you serious and sincere?
Agree.For me he has failed unless he wins the Premier League or Champions league.If this doesn’t happen this season,I don’t see how it will change next season.Man City will just stroll to the title next season,as Chelsea,Man U,Liverpool are way off the pace and again we will be second.The argument not to sack him will be it could be worse but of course if you change manager you might get over the line.However if the club are happy with Arteta and 2nd place and no silverware,why would they change?
Highbury 44,why do you think the owner is happy with second place?
After each season where we finished second, he invested heavily in new players.
The sane goes with your assumption that they don’t want silverware – I’ve not read that anywhere.
The only point that we can agree on, is that they seem happy with MA and why wouldn’t they?
I do think they should wait until the end of the season and then assess the situation.
Because if we end up yet again with no trophies. ,we are in groundhog day.Do you honestly think if the club keep Arteta as the manager it will be any different next year?As i said if the club are happy with this, then he will be offered another contract
All I can say is Actetack should walk away or let’s board let go of him whether he wins trophy 🏆 by summer or not…
I’m freaking tired 😩 of the way we’ve been playing recently as there’s no clue 🧩 on how we play games other safe side ways passes & can any one tell when a zubimendi or any of the midfield trios talkless our defenders lashes a long pass across to any of wingers talkless a central through ball to our impending striker Gorkeres so then why do anyone making excuses for the clown 🤡 of a coach naa!
Just opinion from a Naijafan
It would be extremely harsh to get rid of Arteta if he gets over the line.
I still think we are playing unattractive footy to get over the line. Once we do that, I am sure mindsets will change in terms of the way we play going forward.
Yes,
I think that Arteta is under such pressure that he is trying every method he can to get the title. The style hasn’t been a great watch, but I keep mentioning the home match v Bayer Leverkusen which was absorbing and well played by Arsenal. They do have it in their proverbial locker, so fingers crossed that the fire that he’s on about gets lit tonight with a fiery performance (similar to the spectacle of the AM and Barcelona match which was a humdinger
On another note, Iraola has said he will not be renewing his contract with Bournemouth next season, which could help us.
Guess who their last home game is against? Man City.
The players and fans love Iraola for what he’s done for them, so I am sure they will make a big occasion of this fixture!
The trouble with a manager like Iraola is he hasn’t managed a big club.Managers who go to bigger clubs from mid table clubs often fail and don’t last hardly a season.David Moyes at Man u,Nuno to Spurs and Thomas Frank Spurs.In fact i can’t recall any mid table manager that has made the leap and been successful.If we are going to change we need a manager who has one titles.Imo we should have given Unai Emery more time and money
I agree with your point Highbury44.
However my point was not to go for Iraola as a manager, it was that he will get a great send off in his last game at home for Bournemouth which happens to be against city115, so could be a tough one for city115 due to the occasion.
Our injuries have clearly been disruptive, even with a large squad, but we have to punch through our glass ceiling. No more excuses, we need to win games each and every way we can. Tonight’s game is a big one and many are looking for a statement performance, but let’s just get it done.
Freddy, I don’t know if you are an admirer of William Shakespeare like me. He said that it is in vain to talk to him that means not to understand! However, your attempt to bring calm to charged minds is commendable.
The reason why our noisy neighbour, Spurs is facing the threat of relegation is unrealistic expectations which have led them to change managers as if they were clothing! This all in the pursuit of elusive honours. We should accept our reality that Arteta is one of the best managers around despite his short experience. If we toyed with him, it might take us back to where we were before he came.
I read the article with a lot of amusement because the contributor is a good writer. His ability to put together different issues is highly commendable. You might think you are reading a good literary piece. However, many of his points are subject to scrutiny. How does he know what Arteta discusses with his players unless he is an insider? Secondly, the issue of players is a tricky one. You may recruit a player whom you think will conquer the world but he ends up a disappointment! Take the case of Zubimendi. This is a player every big club was yearning for but he has not fully adapted to EPL because of his physical limitations. Gyokeres is another matter. I believe he has tried his best because right now he is our top scorer. It is not easy to move to a new league and be an instant success but he has truly tried his best.
What is my advice to Freddy? You ahould not stop expressing your views regardless of whether or not some people agree with you. It is fulfilling to be objective even if the majority disagrees with you. There are others in that category like Ken, David and a few others who are never moved by the heat of the moment. In the end, you will be satisfied that you stood by your principles.
David Rusa
Thanks brother. I totally agree with you. Funnily enough, those who want Arteta sacked, are the ones who wanted Wenger and Emery to leave the club. Arteta has transformed this club. Even a certain Spanish journalist said that Arsenal are now a role model to European teams, because of what we have become
For those who are against Arteta, ask them when we last fought for the league 4 seasons in a row while reaching two UCL semis in a row( if we do it tonight). It’s only that Arteta has been facing monsters in Pep And Klopp, who win league titles with 95+ points
There are great moments to come. Funnily enough, if Arteta wins a trophy this season, those who are calling for his head will be here saying how they have always loved and supported him 😆😆😆😆
I don’t want Arteta sacked but I did want Emery out. It was awful and not comparable to the position the club is in currently.
That said, I would be very cautious about renewing Arteta’s contract if the team fail to land one of the remaining trophies. In the heat of the moment after the Bournemouth defeat, I said I think it would be wrong to offer another deal, in part because of the potential fan backlash and also because the internal mood will probably have shifted. A new broom ‘could’ have a beneficial effect (and not because I think that Arteta is a bad manager) On the flip side, the situation could be worse, but sometimes a relationship comes to a natural end, and the water will then have to be tested anyway.
In any case, its not the end of the season so I am maintaining a positive stance until then.
“ However, your attempt to bring calm to charged minds is commendable.”
Haha ,alls he’s doing his slagging off any fan that disagrees with his opinion,read the room for goodness sake .
Absolutely hilarious….
And total cringe once again.
I wont get drawn in to should he stays or should he go (almost sounds lime a record)until the last ball has been kicked which will determine if we win something or not but I would like to point out to some
Up until the weekend We have had more magical moments to to celebrate as a club this season then other teams in The league and by that i mean we had scored the most goals.
Weather it be a set piece or from open play a goal is a goal
The feeling of seeing your team score is second to none. Compounded with winning on top of that there is not a better feeling
Don’t forget the fundamentals which is winning and we have won.more then anyone else and the table doesn’t lie.
As I keep repeating
A few more twists and turns to come
COYG
ONWARD AND UPWARDS
There is a great chance that Arsenal face again 2 top European teams (Atletico in the SF and Munich in the final) which Arsenal already comprehensively beaten them 7-1 earlier in the UCL league phase. COYG!!
Ambachew,
We beat PSG in the league phase last season. Can you remember who won when we met in the knock-out stage?.
Different stage of the tournament and Different rhythm to the teams now
We need to get the job done tonight and SL are a tricky team but not so good away
If we get past them we can take in to the other games the knowledge the the other teams can be beaten
Onwards and upwards
The difference between the 2022 season y’all keep referring to and this is simple “Thomas Party”. There’s a gaping TP shaped hole at the base of that midfield and it influences how the whole team plays because u then see Odengard (when fit) coming all the way back to facilitate play which Rice and Zubi struggle with. To make the team better, I think G. Jesus needs more playing time. He’s the only striker we have that is comfortable dropping in to pick up the bal in pockets of space. Eze and Zubimendi have terrible off the ball positioning and movement that should be drilled into them in training. Haverts should only ever play upfront as he gives us an option for the long balls. and why not try Skelly in the middle of the park?
Arteta this season is very cautious. Last season we were playing each game without fear, we didn’t have a centre forward. This season we Have A Centre forward but we chose a very wrong system of defending even if they is no pressure from our opponents. He must start Saka at position 10 for the remainder of the season. The current midfielders are all playing at defence and helping to delay the game. I6 personally don’t fear any Team, as the only team that can defeat Arsenal is only Arsenal