Arsenal Debate: Why should Ben White play for England if he doesn’t want to?

The Ben White and England situation by Dan

Given that it’s become tradition for me every international break to question why Ben White was not called up by England, it’s only right I give my opinion on our defender asking Edu to inform the FA he doesn’t want to be considered for selection.

Some Gooners point of view is dictated purely by how the situation impacts Arsenal yet as a football fan in general, it’s sad that a 26-year-old feels like he doesn’t want to represent his nation. Especially given that his country has a realistic chance of winning the Euros. Shouldn’t occasions like Germany be something that a sports person dreams of when they are a youngster? Even as a fringe player, would you not want that winners medal?

With injuries at full back, Gareth Southgate thought it would be an insult to our intelligence to suggest that it was football reasons why our right back wasn’t in his latest squad.

The manager then confirmed he’s spoken to the player since the World Cup and wasn’t clear why White was reserved in playing for him again.

Just to clarify, that’s the Three Lions boss admitting he was lying the previous times he stressed that the Gunners omission was based on others being ahead of him.

Since when it is okay for the head coach of England’s most popular sport to mislead the fanbase?

Now knowing he hasn’t been honest how can we believe Mr Southgate when he claims Steve Holland is not the reason for the drama and that he doesn’t know what the issue is?

Isn’t it your job to know?

Are you not being paid millions of pounds a year to get the best out of the talent pool available to you?

If someone is too unhappy to play for you, have you not failed in your job?

You only have to work with the group every few months so surely part of your job specification is to create harmony?

I don’t have the right to know what is happening in someone’s personal life, such as what made Ben White leave Qatar early at the WC.

As someone who pays his money to attend Wembley though, I think supporters can question why an atmosphere has been created that means someone at the peak of his powers would rather sit at home then play Brazil on Saturday?

As an England supporter, I want to know if our dressing room has strong enough clique’s that a player in form no longer wants to participate. That’s another story that materialised from the World Cup. That realising he wasn’t playing; White didn’t feel it was beneficial to spend weeks away from his family in an environment that made him unhappy.

It’s worth stressing that the private issues that meant he had to leave Qatar didn’t prevent him days later joining his club in Dubai. He wasn’t shy on social media at that time pointing out how content he was to be back where he was wanted.

It would be sad if we had a player who lacks the ambition and hunger to not want to be part of a European Championships. He was openly emotional when he earnt his first cap, describing it as a dream and being surreal. So, this notion he’s simply not patriotic doesn’t add up.

This is where I will back Mikel Arteta.

I haven’t always agreed with his man management, but we know the Spaniard won’t tolerate anyone with a bad attitude. From day one he’s preached about non-negotiable principles that he won’t compromise on. In other words, White’s employers wouldn’t be giving him a pay rise if something was wrong with his personality.

In a short statement after White left Qatar, our boss stressed he was of his players reasoning and that Arsenal backed him.

White is eccentric. Somewhat of an enigma in his outlook on football. He and his family are not fans of the game. He doesn’t love the profession, it’s just something he happens to be talented at.

It’s simply his job, a career, a route to making himself rich. While some will find that hard to fathom, it doesn’t make him wrong. Nor does it mean he’s any less committed in training.

A Rashford, Grealish, etc might talk about football when they have finished work, yet they have been less professional then White in their careers.

Those in the media who have worked with White have maintained for days that his approach, while easy to misunderstand as not being passionate, is actually the way he is wired. His thought process gets the very best out of him and maximises his ability.

In his own words, he needs to switch off after work to be able to maximise his end product.

A lot of readers can relate to wanting to switch off when you’re at home and not be thinking about your job.

That might not be conventional in a million-pound industry, filled with glamour but it doesn’t make White wrong.

If that’s his outlook, it then becomes understandable that he wouldn’t want to work where he’s unhappy if he doesn’t have too.

Arsenal are his employers who pay his wages ,no matter if he’s playing at Wembley or if he rests for the next 2 weeks. He legally has zero obligation to play for England.

If you had a choice between being paid to sit at home or be around people who make you unhappy what would you do?

Dan

Tags Ben White England

21 Comments

  1. It’s not been made clear if White has asked not to be selected to play in just this one meaningless friendly, or are we likely to see him this summer in the Euro tournament?
    I’d like him take part, even if it’s on a rotation basis with Kyle Walker or Trent Alexander-Arnold. He’s definitely an international class defender, worthy of playing at the very highest level.

  2. He has a right to do whatever he wants and shouldn’t be criticized for his choice. There are reasons why players play for their country and reasons why they don’t. But it’s up to them. Just respect their choice and move on

    1. I disagree that he “shouldn’t be criticised”, sort of – people have as much right to criticise his decision as he does to make it. However the fact is, anyone who does criticise will be doing so from ignorance, because we don’t know his reasons, as you say.
      If I were him, I’d turn off the noise and just get on with whatever he wants to do – I think that’s exactly what he’s doing.

      1. Davi, yes I see, at least to an extent, your argument and it is true that the right to vitally important free speech and free opinion should always be given to everyone.
        In the tyranny of the illiberal “woke” dullards, it is vital we CONSTANTLY fight to defend free speech!

        But most of all I agree with your final sentence, which is exactly what I would be doing in his place And I AM SURE HE IS.

  3. Unlike retiring from International duty, which is clear cut, this story is interesting because Southgate had previously selected White in tournament squads, with White publicly stating how proud he was to be representing England. Clearly something happened which White wasn’t happy with, and I guess he doesn’t feel comfortable joining back up with the squad at the moment.

    Ultimately, it’s White’s decision, and I respect that, especially if something is going on that’s impacting his mental health.

    And because we don’t have all the facts, it infuriates me when the likes of Harry Redknapp calls White a disgrace, especially in today’s age.

    The only downside is that Maguire will be the main man in defence for yet another tournament. When will it end!!!!

  4. Hi Admin
    I responded to a post by JF earlier and it seems to have disappeared along with other posts
    I’m sure I didn’t write anything remotely contentious so I’m wondering what happened to it
    Thanks

    1. When I delete a post I’m afraid all the responses are also hidden. There is just too much personal abuse being thrown about so I’m going to be busy deleting again this morning once I’m fully awake.

  5. Maybe he wants to concentrate on the sharp end of the season with some seriously important games coming up and sees an international friendly as a distraction. Whatever the reason no one has the right to criticise him, it’s his choice.

  6. Wow, excellent article. I absolutely loved reading it. Resonates my feelings to the core. I completely respect White’s decision and he has the right to keep the reasons to himself. Southgate is a back page caricature waiting to happen. Someone needs to tell him England will never win anything whilst Harry Kane is playing(see Tottenham history and soon to be Bayern😂)and that had he played Rashford instead of Kane in the Euros final, England would have probably beaten Italy in the 90 minutes. Instead the plonker decides to bring on Sancho and Rashford at the end of extra time, to take penalties cold. So is it surprising that both players missed? Sorry, that’s on the manager, if you can call him that, I’d call him more of a Yes man- he’s there because he fits ‘a profile’, he oozes squeaky cleanliness and is a good little puppet for his masters.
    Benny🤍Blanco all the way❤️🤍

  7. I wasn’t aware that White had used social media regarding his return from Qatar. The reasons haven’t been fully disclosed behind his return but mental health was part of the gossip. This was swiftly followed by BW heading off with Arsenal so that theory goes out of the window.

    I heard Redknapp’s rant which was completely uncalled for- especially as he, like the rest of us, don’t know the full facts and it only adds fuel to what is a personal decision made by White

    Maybe it’s because I follow Arsenal that I’m taking his side. The only problem I have is that for some reason he didn’t personally speak to Southgate but let Edu make the call. This made me think that the ‘relationship’ had completely broken down and that GS may have been economical with the truth

  8. As George Graham once said: It’s fine that people hate us. It’s part of our history.
    This “hate” against Ben White is related to him being an Arsenal-player. If he had played for United, Liverpool etc hardly no one would have noticed his NO. Now The Net Hate trying to kill him socially – it’s awful to watch. It’s disgusting.
    And why does Ben White not want to play for England? It’s nobodys business but his. But ask him. If he want to give an answer, let him give that answer, before calling him traitor. I know there are nasty players who like to penalize players from other clubs. It’s Gareth Southgate’s job to stop that. Stop it, Southgate!
    The club must stand up to support Ben White, and defend his right to be the man he is and take the decisions he want. Go Ben, you’re a brave man.

  9. It’s revealed in today’s Mail that Holland asked Ben a question regarding Arsenal’s performance the previous season, which White was unable to answer, and Holland suggested that his lack of interest in football was the reason for not knowing, embarrassing Ben in front of the whole squad. So he left. Simple as that. If true, a little bit immature TBH.
    It was also revealed in the article that Ben turned down the chance to play this time AFTER he’d been selected, not before, and it was Edu who informed England’s FA of his decision.

Comments are closed

Top Blog Sponsors